City of God vs. City of Man (Augustine)
Augustine's City of God (De Civitate Dei, 413–426 CE), written in response to pagans blaming Christianity for Rome's sack by Alaric in 410 CE, establishes the foundational Catholic theological-political framework: the City of God (the community of those predestined for salvation, the church as institution) exists within but is ultimately separate from the City of Man (all earthly political institutions), which are legitimate but temporary accommodations to human sinfulness, making all earthly empires, including Rome, secondary to the eternal divine order.
When Alaric's Visigoths sacked Rome in 410 CE, the first time Rome had been taken by enemies in 800 years, the psychological shock reverberated throughout the Roman world. Pagan critics of Christianity seized on the disaster: Rome had been unconquerable while it worshipped the traditional gods; since Constantine's adoption of Christianity, the empire had weakened and now the Eternal City itself had fallen. Was Christian monotheism, which had offended the traditional gods by abandoning them, responsible for the disaster? Augustine, Bishop of Hippo in North Africa, spent 13 years writing the definitive Christian response.
The City of God's argument is architecturally elegant. Augustine distinguishes two cities, not geographical but theological: the City of God (those who love God above all else, ultimately predestined for salvation) and the City of Man (those who love themselves above God, organized in earthly political institutions). These two cities are mixed together on earth until the Last Judgment separates them. Earthly political institutions, including Rome at its greatest, belong entirely to the City of Man: they can achieve relative justice and external peace, but they cannot achieve salvation or ultimate goodness, because they are built on self-love and the lust for power (libido dominandi).
The implications for political theology were vast. By asserting that the church (as the institutional expression of the City of God) was ultimately superior to any earthly state, Augustine laid the groundwork for the medieval Catholic claim to authority over secular rulers. By making Rome's fall theologically comprehensible (earthly empires are always temporary), he robbed pagan critics of their argument and provided Christians a framework for understanding political catastrophe without theological despair. Predictive History identifies Augustine's City of God as the intellectual architecture of the Catholic Church's millennium-long Western dominance, and his concept of predestination (fully developed in this work) as the direct ancestor of Calvin's Protestantism and the theological driver of the work ethic Max Weber identified as capitalism's cultural foundation.
Related articles
Related terms
Frequently asked questions
What is Augustine's City of God about? ＋
Written in response to pagans blaming Christianity for Rome's sack (410 CE), City of God distinguishes two communities: the City of God (those predestined for salvation, the church) and the City of Man (earthly political institutions built on self-love). All earthly empires, including Rome, belong to the City of Man: they can achieve relative peace but not salvation. The church is ultimately superior to any state. This framework justified Catholic political authority over secular rulers throughout the medieval period.