Culture Wars
Culture wars refer to the intensifying conflict in American (and Western) politics between two incompatible visions of national identity and social values, broadly, a conservative Christian vision prioritizing traditional moral codes and national identity versus a secular progressive vision prioritizing individual rights, diversity, and cosmopolitanism. The term captures something real: these are not just policy disputes but rival conceptions of what America fundamentally is.
Sociologist James Davison Hunter coined the term 'culture war' in his 1991 book Culture Wars: The Struggle to Define America. His insight was that American politics had shifted from economic to cultural conflict, from debates about who gets what resources to debates about what values should govern society. The new fault line was not class but orthodoxy versus progressivism: traditional religious authority versus modern secular individualism.
Predictive History traces the culture wars back to America's founding duality. Two incompatible visions of America coexisted from the beginning: the Puritan-descended vision of a white Christian nation governed by biblical law, and the Enlightenment-descended vision of a multicultural, secular republic governed by reason. For most of American history, these visions were in tension but not in open conflict, the dominant culture was Christian enough to satisfy the first camp while formally secular enough to satisfy the second. From the 1960s onwards, the cultural revolution challenged every aspect of the traditionalist vision simultaneously: racial integration, feminism, sexual liberation, secularism in schools, and mass immigration. The traditionalist response took 30 years to fully mobilize, and arrived in 1994 (Contract with America), 2010 (Tea Party), and finally 2016 (Trump).
The deepening of inequality has intensified the culture wars because economic anxiety and cultural displacement tend to reinforce each other. A white working-class man who has lost his manufacturing job, cannot afford a house, and sees his son unable to find stable employment will find that his economic grievances and his cultural grievances, about immigration, about elite condescension, about his community's declining status, merge into a single, potent rage. Trump's genius was recognizing and naming this merged grievance.
Related articles
Frequently asked questions
What are the culture wars? ＋
The culture wars are the conflict between two incompatible American visions: a conservative Christian nationalist vision of America as a God-ordained white Christian nation, and a secular progressive vision of America as a multicultural democracy governed by reason. These aren't just policy disagreements, they're rival answers to the fundamental question of what America is, making compromise structurally difficult.
Why are America's culture wars getting worse? ＋
Because economic inequality and cultural displacement reinforce each other. Rising inequality has made working-class economic anxiety more acute; mass immigration and demographic change have intensified cultural anxiety simultaneously. When economic grievances and cultural grievances merge into a single identity, as they have for much of Trump's base, the political conflict becomes existential rather than merely transactional.