Trial of Socrates
The trial of Socrates in 399 BCE, in which Athens's democratic jury convicted the 70-year-old philosopher of impiety and corrupting the youth, sentencing him to death by hemlock, is history's most consequential philosophical event, one that forced his student Plato to conclude that democracy was incompatible with truth-seeking and produced the foundational texts of Western philosophy.
Socrates was tried in 399 BCE, four years after Athens's catastrophic defeat in the Peloponnesian War and the subsequent oligarchic coup by the Thirty Tyrants. The context is essential: Athens was traumatized, its democratic confidence shattered, looking for explanations and scapegoats. Socrates had long-standing associations with anti-democratic figures, Alcibiades, the charismatic general who had betrayed Athens, and Critias, the most brutal of the Thirty Tyrants, had both been students of his. The charges (impiety and corrupting the youth) were legal vehicles for a political grievance.
The trial itself, described in Plato's Apology, is Socrates at his most provocative. When given the opportunity to propose an alternative punishment and potentially save his life, he proposed the state feed him for free at public expense, a response designed to force the jury to either acquit him completely or condemn him to death, because anything in between would suggest he took the charges seriously. The jury condemned him. He refused a rescue plan organized by his friends (described in the Crito) on the grounds that escaping would undermine the very legal system he claimed to respect.
Plato's response to the trial was the founding of his Academy and the writing of the Republic, the argument that democracy, which executes its best minds when they threaten comfortable assumptions, requires a class of philosopher-guardians trained in genuine truth before being permitted to govern. The trial of Socrates is thus the origin event of political philosophy's central question: who should rule, and why?
Related terms
Frequently asked questions
Why was Socrates put on trial? ＋
Socrates was formally charged with impiety and corrupting Athenian youth, but the real context was political: four years after Athens's defeat in the Peloponnesian War, with democracy under pressure, Socrates's associations with anti-democratic figures like Alcibiades and Critias made him a convenient target. His daily public humiliation of prominent Athenians through his questioning had created powerful personal enemies over decades.
Why didn't Socrates escape when he had the chance? ＋
Socrates's friend Crito organized a rescue and escape plan before the execution, which Socrates refused. His reasoning, preserved in Plato's Crito, was that escaping would undermine the legal system he had spent his life supporting, if you benefit from the law when it protects you, you cannot reject it when it convicts you. He accepted death as the logical consequence of his philosophical position on civic obligation.