Historical Materialism
Historical Materialism is Marx's theory of historical change, developed from Hegel's idealist dialectic by 'standing it on its head', which holds that the driving force of history is not the development of ideas (Geist) but the development of material productive forces and the social relations of production (who owns what, and how production is organized): the economic 'base' determines the cultural, legal, and political 'superstructure,' and history's stages (primitive communism, ancient slavery, feudalism, capitalism, socialism, communism) are driven by contradictions between productive forces and the property relations constraining them.
Marx's reversal of Hegel: for Hegel, material history was the expression of Spirit's development; for Marx, the development of material productive forces was primary, and ideas, culture, religion, and politics were its expressions. The famous formulation: 'It is not the consciousness of men that determines their existence, but their social existence that determines their consciousness' (Preface to A Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy, 1859). Religion, philosophy, law, and art are not independent forces shaping history but reflections of the material conditions within which they develop, the 'superstructure' that the economic 'base' produces and maintains.
The mechanism of historical change operates through contradictions within the productive system. Each mode of production contains its own internal contradictions: in feudalism, the emerging merchant class (bourgeoisie) creates wealth through trade and manufacture that the feudal land-based property system cannot accommodate, producing the bourgeois revolutions (English Civil War, French Revolution, American Revolution) that clear away feudal impediments to capitalist development. In capitalism, the working class (proletariat) creates all value through labor but receives only a fraction of it, the surplus value appropriated by the capitalist class (profit). This contradiction generates class conflict that will eventually produce proletarian revolution and communism.
Predictive History's evaluation: Historical Materialism's base-superstructure model is one of the most powerful analytical frameworks in social science, with genuine predictive value, economic conditions do strongly shape political and cultural developments. The specific predictions (capitalism's internal contradictions producing proletarian revolution in the most industrialized societies) have proven wrong: communist revolution occurred in agricultural Russia and China, not industrial Britain and Germany. More fundamentally, Marx's model is deterministic in a way that underestimates the independent causal role of ideas, culture, and individual agency, the same idealist variables he displaced. Predictive History uses Historical Materialism as a partial framework, corrected by incorporating the cultural and individual variables Marx excluded.
Related articles
Related terms
Frequently asked questions
What is Historical Materialism? ＋
Marx's theory that material productive forces (not ideas) drive history. The economic 'base' (who owns production, how it's organized) determines the cultural, legal, and political 'superstructure.' Historical stages progress through internal contradictions: feudalism's contradiction (emerging bourgeoisie vs. land-based property system) produced bourgeois revolutions; capitalism's contradiction (workers create all value but receive fraction) will produce proletarian revolution. Predictive History: the base-superstructure model is genuinely powerful; the specific predictions (revolution in most industrialized societies) proved wrong.